If you are looking to get back to basics, there is nothing better than a charcoal smoker.
Pellet and electric smokers are great, but they can’t match the taste of smoke that only a true charcoal smoker can really infuse into meat. It takes a little more skill, but it’s worth the effort.
There are a wide variety of charcoal smokers with great reviews that make smoking fun and tasty, be it a weekend warrior or a grill expert.
The Final Sear: The Weber Smokey Mountain is my favourite charcoal smoker. It comes in three different sizes and is an absolute classic, why mess with perfection.
Below are our top best researched picks for this category.
Top 10 Coal Smokers in 2020
- 784 square inches
- 20.2 x 34.5 x 47 inches
- 286 square inches
- 31.4 X 14.7 X 14.7 inches
- 21.2 x 23 x 37, 6 inches
1. Weber 711001 Smokey Mountain Cooker Charcoal Smoker
This is a classic and durable Weber design that achieves the highest ratings of any smoker on this list. If you don’t object to a bullet-shaped coal option, look no further. Really.
This rugged comes in different sizes: 14 “, 18” and 22 “if you need to upgrade your game. The 14 inch model is a great beginner model and offers 286 square inches, which can comfortably handle two rib shelves at at the same time with a bit of headroom.
Features a built-in lid mounted thermometer, easily accessible water pan, charcoal chamber and fuel door.
The Smokey Mountain includes 2 enameled cooking grates and silicone temperature washers to accurately track internal temperatures.
The damper system allows full control of the smoker’s internal heat without lifting the lid and killing your smoke retention. Extinguishing the coals is also easy: simply close all damper vents to cut off oxygen flow.
Overall construction is porcelain enamelled for retention of c High level value.
This is a sweet little model that is sized just for over any space and can even be packed for camping or boating if you are looking for something portable.
2. Dyna-Glo DGO1176BDC-D Smoker Offset Smoker
In the carbon category, this is a solid mid-range option from Dyna-Glo.
This is a big boy with 784 square inches of total smoking area who can accommodate approximately 100 pounds of meat at any given time. It offers a single 15,000 BTU cast iron burner and six height adjustable stainless steel cooking grates.
The unique offset design optimizes the benefits of indirect heat flow that is imperative for slow cooking and infusing the maximum smoky flavor.
A Front mounted analog thermometer, adjustable smoke stack, electric impulse ignition, and porcelain enamelled charcoal chamber allowing for more efficient stacking of briquettes completes the list of features.
The overall construction is steel with a high temperature powder coating intended to withstand high temperatures and optimize long term durability. A double door helps lock temperatures to maximize heat retention.
This is a sweet little offset option if you’re looking for an alternative to the two bullet-style models in our top two spots for this category.
3. Char-Broil Bullet Charcoal Smoker, 16 ″
Slightly shorter than the 16 & # 39; & # 39; Weber, this is another favorite charcoal smoker with basic features that users really rave about.
The internal space is slightly more spacious at 370 square inches with two porcelain-coated cooking grates that adjust to their ideal height inside the chamber.
The Bullet also includes a smart airflow control system that simplifies temperature regulation with easy-to-use numbered gate configurations, even if it’s new to the game, you can end up with some big smoke.
The main body is also porcelain-coated for durability, and two camera lift handles and a lid-mounted temperature gauge complete the external features.
The ashtray is also easy to remove and tilt when finished cleaning quickly and easily.
This is a great little coal option that is really reasonably priced so it won’t break the bank.
Most of the grills on this list are bullet-shaped smokers, but this version of Backwoods offers a vertical dome-style alternative .
This is the luxury grill in this group with a “chubby” ”, but the overall quality of this grill is next level and deserves the additional cost.
The total size in Chubby is 29 & # 39; & # 39; high with 4 stainless steel grids and 1 additional slider for grille adjustment. In terms we can all understand, that means this big boy can hold 8 pieces of ribs, 2 to 3 skirts, or 2 to 4 Boston butts.
The cooking range is 180 to 300 degrees and the design includes a front mounted analog thermometer. The lower chamber is spacious and can accommodate 6-10 pounds of coal at any given time.
Internal construction is stainless steel in the cook chamber for maximum thermal insulation, a double wall design optimizes reverse flow.
This is a beautiful beast of a smoker and if you are looking for the last smoke you need to buy then you have found it here.
5. Cuisinart COS-118 Vertical 18 ″ Smoke Smoke Smoker
This is another fun little bullet shaped smoker that offers the same height dimension as the Weber.
Internal cooking space is 510 square inches with two stainless steel grates that can be repositioned as needed depending on what you are smoking. It includes a porcelain enameled steel water bowl and features a vertical side door for easy access to both water and fuel.
Two air vents allow greater control over the levels of heat and air within the smoker and the two air vents can be opened. or closed to manage both variables.
Cuisinart also makes a version of 16 & # 39; & # 39; if you don’t need as much cooking space; all other features remain the same.
The size of the COS-118 also makes it a great choice if you need something portable that can accompany you on your next camping adventure.
6. Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D Heavy Duty Vertical Compensation Smoker & Charcoal Rotator
So this is the mega version of the Dyna-Glo Sweet Smoker with Compensation # 2.
This is a Large & # 39; UN with 1382 square inches of total cooking area and five chrome cooking grates.
What’s exciting about this model is that it includes an extra large charcoal grill and an ashtray that offers easy access to fuel and simple ash removal. . It is also removable, which is a good advantage.
Additional features include a cold-touch spring handle, an analog temperature gauge with a “smoke zone” range so you know when you’re hitting the sweet spot, and pre-installed sausage hooks for more flexibility in options cooking.
General construction is heavy gauge steel for maximum durability and heat retention.
7. Realcook Vertical 17 Inch Steel Charcoal Smoker
This is a solid budget option if you’re only interested in smoking coal.
It is a mid-size option with 453 total square inches of cooking space with three layers of interlocking chamber that can be separated for easy cleaning, and two cooking grates. There are also 4 hangers built into the lid for sausages or jerky.
This model also includes a built-in analog thermometer, a porcelain enameled water pan, and a carbon can, in addition to the adjustable air supply on the lid to control both temperature and smoke intensity.
The double door design is an added bonus and allows you to access the cameras separately. The bottom door also makes it easy to add charcoal or water.
It is also worth noting that the two main layers can also be separated and used for traditional barbecue rather than smoking for a little extra versatility.
8. SUNLIFER 19.5 Inch Vertical Charcoal Smoker, Barbecue Grill
Like the Realcook, the Sunlifer can be used for its main smoker role, or the layers can be separated to use as a traditional charcoal grill or even a fire pit.
This is a larger model with 876 square inches of total cooking area and three chrome players for cooking grates. Includes a crossbar and cap-mounted hooks for more flexibility in what you’re smoking, including sausages.
Additional features include 2 adjustable air vents for temperature and smoke control, a built-in front mount thermometer, and a heavy duty stainless steel for durability.
It also offers a double door system so that the different layers can be easily accessed individually.
Layered design also makes it an easy grill to carry and use as a portable smoker and grill combo when camping or with friends and family.
9. Masterbuilt MB20040220 Gravity Series 560 Digital Charcoal Smoker Grill
The Gravity 560 series is the only digital cart-style smoker on the list and a great choice if you don’t like bullet or vault style setups.
Includes two porcelain coated grills for a total of 560 square inches of cooking space. The coal hopper has a capacity of 10 pounds of lump coal or the equivalent of 16 pounds of briquettes for 12-15 hours of life.
Includes a built-in analog temperature meter, a digital fan for precise temperature control, a digital control panel that can also be paired with a smartphone, a meat probe thermometer for precise temperature control internal and reversible smoke and cast iron grilles.
The left side table is a good addition for prep work and the bottom cart is great for storing grilling accessories and must-have tools.
Warm-ups are fast, the 560 can reach 225 degrees in 7 minutes or can heat up to 700 degrees in 13 minutes.
This is a great option with a bigger footprint if you have a little more space in the backyard and are looking for something digital.
10. Best Choice Products 43-Inch 3-Piece Outdoor BBQ Charcoal Smoker
Another camera design, this is a 43 & # 39; & # 39; s big boy.
Includes top-mounted air vents to monitor temperature and smoke intensity, a lid-mounted thermometer, and a hooked base that provides easy access to all necessities: coal, water, and ashtray.
A horizontally hinged door design provides access to the center shelf. All three chambers can be configured to personalize your smoking project and includes two chrome racks.
This is one of the least expensive options on our list and a solid budget choice if you are more of a weekend warrior who has just entered the smoking world.
Note: When you buy something after clicking the links in our articles, we can earn a small commission. Read our affiliate link policy for more details.